Skip to content
The Encyclopedia of Horology

Identification · 4 min

Researching an Unsigned Clock

An unsigned clock can still be described well when its movement, case, dial and later alterations are recorded separately and compared with documented examples.

Related photographs

Pendulum-with-Escapement
Pendulum-with-Escapement — Silas Ellsworth Coleman, Public domain. Wikimedia Commons file page
Anchor escapement
Anchor escapement — Timwether, CC BY-SA 3.0. Wikimedia Commons file page
Anchor escapement
Anchor escapement — George Henry Abbott Hazlitt, Public domain. Wikimedia Commons file page
Graham escapement
Graham escapement — Ssawka, Original uploader was Ssawka at pl.wikipedia, CC BY-SA 3.0. Wikimedia Commons file page
Anchor escapement - Wikipedia | Grandfather clock, Clock, Mechanical clock
Anchor escapement - Wikipedia | Grandfather clock, Clock, Mechanical clock — ar.pinterest.com, Rights unverified — web image search result, review pending. Web page (ar.pinterest.com)
Model of anchor escapement | Science Museum Group Collection
Model of anchor escapement | Science Museum Group Collection — collection.sciencemuseumgroup.org.uk, Rights unverified — web image search result, review pending. Web page (collection.sciencemuseumgroup.org.uk)

No confidently matched photograph of this subject has been found yet. These photographs show a closely related record, and are not examples of the type described on this page.

Begin with the evidence the clock gives you, not with a maker's name. Photograph the case, dial, hands, pendulum, weights, movement front and back, seatboard, inside doors and backboard before cleaning or moving labels. Retain pencil inscriptions, repairers' scratch marks and paper labels exactly as found. A name inside the case may be a repairer, owner, retailer or carrier rather than the maker, so its location and form matter as much as the words.

Movement construction is the strongest first comparison. Record whether the clock is weight- or spring-driven, the plate shape, pillar form, train count if visible, escapement type and striking arrangement. Countwheel striking, rack-and-snail striking, quarter striking, alarm work and platform escapements belong to different traditions and periods. Do not dismantle a movement to chase a hidden mark; a clockmaker can inspect under the dial and behind plates without unnecessary disturbance.

The dial should be treated as its own object. Brass dials, painted iron dials, silvered chapter rings, falseplates, spandrels, calendar apertures and moon-phase work all narrow the research field, but they can be replaced. Photograph the back of a dial only when it can be removed safely by a specialist, because falseplate names and dial-maker marks may identify the dial supplier rather than the clockmaker. Dial style is useful evidence, not a complete attribution.

Case evidence is important but must be cross-checked. Woods, veneer, hood shape, trunk mouldings, feet and door glazing can place a clock within a regional fashion, while later repairs can deliberately copy older forms. Empty screw holes, altered seatboards, packed cheeks, dial misalignment and mismatched winding holes may suggest a married case and movement. Record those observations without turning every mismatch into an accusation: longcase clocks were repaired, recased and adapted over generations.

A good comparison set uses signed and accessioned examples rather than search-result thumbnails. Look for clocks with the same plate layout, striking system and dial construction, then compare case form and inscriptions. Trade directories and parish records can show which makers worked in a town, but they cannot connect one unsigned clock to a person unless the clock carries direct evidence or a distinctive documented construction.

Write a bounded conclusion. 'Eight-day rack-striking longcase clock, painted dial, probably northern England, early nineteenth century; maker unidentified' is more useful than a guessed signature. Keep open questions visible: whether the case and movement started together, whether the dial is original, which repairs are documented and which marks remain unread. That record can be revised when stronger evidence appears without undoing an unsupported claim.

Research help and reference tools

The NAWCC's Fortunat Mueller-Maerki Library & Research Center in Columbia, Pennsylvania, describes itself as one of the largest libraries in the world devoted to time and timekeeping, holding books, videos, catalogues, periodicals and archival material. For an identification request it asks for clear photographs of the case, dial and movement and of every name, number or trademark on them, transcribed where the pictures are unclear. It also asks for whatever is known of the object's history, when, where and from whom it was acquired and who else owned it, together with its dimensions. Members' questions are answered free and non-members pay a reference fee, with members' questions given priority.

The NAWCC's online index of identification and dating aids gathers trademark databases, among them a list of more than 1,000 German makers' marks and searchable indexes of horological trademarks, stamps and signatures. For early American clocks it points to the Labels & Printers Project, which uses the printer named on a clock's paper label to date the clock. It also lists a spreadsheet for identifying Terry-type wooden movements compiled with the Cog Counters, and a database of clockmakers' names and dates.

Written from the guidance and records listed under Sources, credited to each publisher and put in our own words; each statement was checked against the cited page.

Evidence sequence for an unsigned clock

Evidence sequence for an unsigned clock
EvidenceUseful forLimit
Movement constructionEscapement, striking system, plate form and train layout.Can suggest region or period, not a named maker alone.
Dial and falseplateDial maker, layout, calendar or moon-work clues.May be replaced or supplied by another trade.
Case and seatboardFit, adaptation, regional style and marriage evidence.Style can persist or be revived.
Hidden marks and labelsRepair history, retailer, owner or possible maker leads.A name must be interpreted from its location.

Evidence checklist

  1. Photograph before cleaning.
  2. Record movement, dial and case separately.
  3. Use signed comparisons before naming a maker.

A bounded unidentified description is a successful result when direct attribution evidence is absent.